“What a Friend We Have in Jesus” began as a private poem. Joseph Scriven, an Irish-born tutor and lay preacher living in Ontario, wrote it around 1855 to comfort his mother, who was far away in Ireland and in grief. He never put it in his own book, and the people who knew him best did not realise he had written it until he was an old man. This is what the surviving record shows about the poem, the tune that was added years later, the printing mix-up that credited the wrong poet, and the man himself.
Quick Answer
“What a Friend We Have in Jesus” is a prayer hymn by Joseph Medlicott Scriven (1819–1886). He wrote the text around 1855 in Canada West, now Ontario, for his mother. It was first printed without his name in H. L. Hastings’ Social Hymns, Original and Selected (Boston, 1865). The usual tune, called Converse after its composer Charles Crozat Converse, was first published with the words in Silver Wings (1870). Ira Sankey then carried the hymn into Gospel Hymns and Sacred Songs (1875), where it was wrongly credited to Horatius Bonar. Scriven was not named in the Gospel Hymns series until 1887. The text and tune are in the public domain.
Who Joseph Scriven Was
Scriven was born on 10 September 1819 in Banbridge, County Down, the son of John Scriven and Jane Medlicott. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography says he attended Addiscombe Military College near London from 1837 to 1839, preparing for service in India, but withdrew for reasons of health. He took a BA at Trinity College, Dublin, in 1842 and joined the Plymouth Brethren, the same movement his parents had joined.
In 1845 he joined Brethren friends in Woodstock, Canada West. He taught there and then in Brantford, where he ran a private school for two or three years in the early 1850s and held religious services. From 1855 he lived in Huron County, near what is now Clinton, and often read the Bible to the men building the Grand Trunk Railway to Goderich, “getting small thanks for his pains.” About 1857 he moved to Bewdley, near Port Hope, as tutor in the household of a retired naval officer, Robert Lamport Pengelly.
Later biographers describe a life marked by loss. The tradition, repeated in many popular accounts and noted by the Hymnology Archive, is that his first fiancée drowned in Ireland. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography does not mention her, so treat that detail as tradition rather than record. What is documented is that in Canada he became engaged to Pengelly’s niece, Eliza Catherine Roach, who fell ill and died in August 1860.
The Poem He Wrote for His Mother
The Hymnology Archive collects the evidence. Scriven gave away several handwritten copies of the poem, and the surviving accounts agree on the reason. The earliest known draft sits on the back cover of a small handwritten booklet that Scriven gave to a family in Brantford in the early 1850s. Edward Caswell printed it in Canadian Singers and Their Songs (1919), headed “Pray without ceasing,” a phrase from 1 Thessalonians 5:17. That draft has sixteen lines, against twenty-four in the version we sing.
In a letter dated 8 January 1887, Scriven’s friend James Sackville wrote that the hymn “was never published by the author in any book or paper. He sent one copy to his own mother and handed another copy to my mother about the year 1855; and until very recently his most intimate friends did not know that he was the author of it.” The Hymnology Archive thinks Sackville probably misdated the copy given to his own family, but treats his account as close enough to be reliable.
Scriven’s father, John, had died on 21 December 1850, so the poem reached his mother as a widow. It is a hymn written for one person in a hard season, and that is why the first stanza reads like a plain instruction:
What a friend we have in Jesus,
All our sins and griefs to bear!
What a privilege to carry
Everything to God in prayer!
Sankey later recorded what Scriven said when a neighbour in Port Hope asked whether it was true that he had written the hymn: “The Lord and I did it between us.” Sankey tells this in My Life and the Story of the Gospel Hymns (1906), long after the events, so read it as a recollection rather than a transcript.
How It Reached the Page: 1865 and 1870
Some writers say the hymn was first printed in Dublin from the copy sent to Scriven’s mother. The Hymnology Archive says no such early printing has been found. The first confirmed appearance is in H. L. Hastings’ Social Hymns, Original and Selected (Boston, 1865), unsigned, in three eight-line stanzas and without music.
The tune came five years later. Charles Crozat Converse (1834–1918) published it in Silver Wings (Boston: Oliver Ditson, 1870) under his pen name Karl Reden, a German rendering of his own surname. Converse credited the words to a Brooklyn church collection, which has not survived. A popular story says he heard of the poem from a salesman with a newspaper clipping in Erie, Pennsylvania, but the Hymnology Archive points out that Converse was living in New York in 1870 and did not move to Erie until 1875, so the story does not hold up.
The Sankey Mix-Up
The hymn’s fame in the English-speaking world came through Ira Sankey. His account is that, after the first Gospel Hymns was already with its publishers in 1875, he found the words in a small Sunday-school hymn pamphlet from Richmond, Virginia, and swapped in the hymn in place of one of Converse’s own pieces. In his words, the last hymn into the book became one of the first in favour.
The pamphlet credited the words to the Scottish hymn writer Horatius Bonar, and Sankey repeated that. Bonar later said he had not written it and did not know who had. His name came out of later editions, and Scriven was finally credited in Gospel Hymns No. 5 in 1887, a year after his death. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography adds that Hastings first ascribed it to Scriven in a collection of 1886.
One more wrinkle: the fourth stanza that many congregations know first appeared in Hastings’ Songs of Pilgrimage (1886), labelled “Joseph Scriven, cir. 1855.” The Hymnology Archive notes that with Scriven’s manuscripts lost, nobody can confirm that he wrote it. A 1971 Canadian hymnal also alters the last stanza. If a service leaflet shows a fourth stanza, you are singing text of uncertain authorship.
What Happened to Scriven
Scriven moved from the Pengelly household to a cottage in Port Hope in the late 1860s or early 1870s and spent his time tutoring, preaching and helping neighbours. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography records that he sawed wood for people who could not pay and sold his Irish watch to replace a widow’s lost cow. In 1869 he published Hymns and Other Verses in Peterborough, with 115 poems, and left out the one that would make him known.
He died on 10 August 1886 near Bewdley, at the home of his friend Sackville. He had been ill and left his bed on a hot night, probably to drink from a spring, and was found in the nearby mill spillway. He was buried in the Pengelly burial ground between Eliza Roach and Commander Pengelly. In 1920 a monument carrying the hymn was unveiled over his grave.
The Dictionary of Canadian Biography notes a slightly awkward fact: almost all of Scriven’s other hymns are more firmly constructed than this one, yet this is the only one that circulated widely. Caswell called it “beyond question the best-known piece of Canadian literature.”
Reading the Hymn
The hymn names no single Bible verse, but the ideas run through it. The earliest draft is headed with 1 Thessalonians 5:17, and the Hymnology Archive connects the text with Psalm 55:22 (“Cast thy burden upon the Lord”). Its structure is simple: each stanza names a burden (sins and griefs, trials and temptations, weakness) and answers it with the same move, take it to Jesus in prayer.
It is also a hymn that has been criticised. The 1941 Handbook to the Lutheran Hymnal noted that the hymn and its tune have been criticised as too sentimental, a gospel-song type, while adding that its popularity remains strong. The Hymnology Archive quotes the editors of the Companion to Church Hymnal (2000), who found Converse’s tune dull and praised an alternative, Manor House by Frederick G. Carter, written for the 1960 Irish Church Hymnal. Both views are useful: you can sing it with either tune, and you can lead it without pretending it is a theological treatise.
It also travels well. Wikipedia lists translations including Hindi (“Yeshu kaisa dost pyara”), Malayalam (“Enthu nallore sakhi Yesu,” hymn 173 in Christhiya Keerthanangal) and Telugu (“Preethi gala mana Yesu”), and notes that the Hindi version is common at Passion week and burial services.
Using It in Church
- Services of comfort. It fits funerals, hospital visits and prayer meetings better than a Sunday opener. See our guides to Christian music for grief and loss and Christian music for funerals.
- Tell one true sentence. “He wrote it for his mother when she was ill and far away” changes how people hear the first line, and it is all documented. Leave out the drowning story unless you present it as tradition.
- Pair it with another hymn of trust. It sits well beside It Is Well with My Soul or Just As I Am, and for a slower, more reflective set, Abide with Me.
- Keep the tempo steady and the stanzas few. Three stanzas are enough, and a congregation that knows the tune will carry it.
- Check the version before you print it. Scriven’s 1855 text, the 1865 printing and Converse’s 1870 tune are in the public domain. A newer arrangement, an altered last stanza or a recording can still be protected. Our worship song credit and licensing checklist shows what to log, and how to build a worship set covers where a hymn like this fits in a service.
For the wider case for keeping hymns like this in rotation, see why ancient hymns still matter.
FAQ
Who wrote “What a Friend We Have in Jesus”?
Joseph Medlicott Scriven (1819–1886), an Irish-born tutor and preacher who lived in Ontario. Charles Crozat Converse wrote the usual tune.
When was it written?
Around 1855, according to a letter from Scriven’s friend James Sackville. The first confirmed printing is from 1865, and the tune with the words was published in 1870.
Why did Scriven write it?
By the accounts collected by the Hymnology Archive, he wrote it to comfort his mother in Ireland during a time of sorrow. He did not intend it for publication.
Was it really written by Horatius Bonar?
No. Early printings, including Sankey’s 1875 Gospel Hymns, credited Bonar by mistake. Bonar said he had not written it, and Scriven was credited from 1887.
Is “What a Friend We Have in Jesus” in the public domain?
The 1855 text, the 1865 printing and Converse’s 1870 tune are in the public domain. Modern arrangements, altered stanzas and recordings may still be protected, so check the source before you print, project or stream them.
Sources
Hymnology Archive: What a friend we have in Jesus
Dictionary of Canadian Biography: Scriven, Joseph Medlicott
